My Aai made nankatai quite often(it definitely is nankatai and not nankhatai at least for us). Technically she didn't bake them, rather they were baked for us by a local bakery. We provided the raw material in the correct amounts (sometime even the prepared dough) and they did the rest. This happy errand was always mine. After handing over the ingredients/ dough, the clever thing to do was to arrive at the bakery a few minutes ahead of the pickup time. As more often than not, the baker would offer something right out of the oven. It could be a waati-cake (literally cake baked in a katori), a plain bun, or a khari biscuit. Bliss!
Since Aai's nankatai was made with Dalda (as was the nankatai made by my mother-in-law), I never thought of making nankatai any other way.
Recently I tasted nankatai made using butter. What a difference! It was so decadent.
The difference was not only in the taste, but in the texture as well. The vegetable shortening nankatai seemed much lighter and finer in texture than it's makhan counterpart.
Recently I tasted nankatai made using butter. What a difference! It was so decadent.
The difference was not only in the taste, but in the texture as well. The vegetable shortening nankatai seemed much lighter and finer in texture than it's makhan counterpart.
Shortening is not the healthiest thing to use, but I don't worry about that too much as I make nankatai just a couple of times a year. Also, this is the only thing I prepare using vegetable shortening.
I especially like the texture of the vegetable shortening nankatai because of the associated childhood food memories and so continue to make it that way.
Though the the shortening contributes to the texture and general appearance, it does very little in the flavour department. Nothing a pinch of keshar and elaichi cannot fix. For even more flavour, I add some powdered almonds.
Though the the shortening contributes to the texture and general appearance, it does very little in the flavour department. Nothing a pinch of keshar and elaichi cannot fix. For even more flavour, I add some powdered almonds.
My kids just absolutely love this nankatai. Even more than chocolate-chip cookies, so that is saying something. It makes me happy to share my childhood foods and the memories that go with them. To see them enjoy such foods while (hopefully) forming memories of their own makes me uncharacteristically sappy!
Ingredients
½ cup sugar
½ vegetable shortening
a pinch of saffron, soaked in a little water
elaichi powder, to taste
3-4 tbsp ground almonds (optional)
½ to ¾ cups all purpose flour
Method
Preheat oven to 350F.
Grease a cookie sheet and set aside.
Cream together the shortening and sugar till the mixture is light and fluffy. A hand mixer works best for this task.
Add the saffron, elaichi, and almonds if using.
Add ½ cup all purpose flour. Using your hands knead this dough slightly.
Add more flour as you go along. You want a dough that is soft and moist. Do not add more than 1½ times the quantity of the shortening used.
Use your finger tips to pull off a piece of the dough, or you could use a melon-baller. Roll in between your palms to form a ball.
Place the cookies on the sheet, about 2 inches apart. Sometimes I press each cookie with the tines of a fork.
Bake for about 15 minutes (oven times may vary).
After 10 minutes, keep a close eye on the cookie.
Take them out of the oven at the first sign of any browning around the edges.
Let them cool slightly before using letting anyone steal them for taste-testing purposes.
Enjoy!
½ cup sugar
½ vegetable shortening
a pinch of saffron, soaked in a little water
elaichi powder, to taste
3-4 tbsp ground almonds (optional)
½ to ¾ cups all purpose flour
Method
Preheat oven to 350F.
Grease a cookie sheet and set aside.
Cream together the shortening and sugar till the mixture is light and fluffy. A hand mixer works best for this task.
Add the saffron, elaichi, and almonds if using.
Add ½ cup all purpose flour. Using your hands knead this dough slightly.
Add more flour as you go along. You want a dough that is soft and moist. Do not add more than 1½ times the quantity of the shortening used.
Use your finger tips to pull off a piece of the dough, or you could use a melon-baller. Roll in between your palms to form a ball.
Place the cookies on the sheet, about 2 inches apart. Sometimes I press each cookie with the tines of a fork.
Bake for about 15 minutes (oven times may vary).
After 10 minutes, keep a close eye on the cookie.
Take them out of the oven at the first sign of any browning around the edges.
Let them cool slightly before using letting anyone steal them for taste-testing purposes.
Enjoy!

25 comments:
wow..they look tempting...
YUM YUM! Simple cookies are always the best!:))
HAVE to try this out very soon, lloks lovely!
kay ga mulgi, doesn't ghee work?
That photo just takes me right back to the local bakeries in my neighbourhood. My q is the same as Bee's...
they looks so delish, my ma used to put an orange dot in the middle of the nank(h)atai
Seems to be a simple cookie recipe here.
Oh I love Nankatai. Haven't made this since long. Simple yet so delicious right/ Nice picture.
Oh !! I love nankatai!!! this takes me back to my childhood hen my Dad would bring a bag every saturday!!!
Thanks for stooping by to admire the nankatai.
Bee & Ashwini: yes, ghee does work here as does butter. But then it won't be my Aai's version of nankatai. Also, it is the familiarity of the texture that what makes me reach for the veg. shortening when making this.
yum :)
looks like everyone has fond memories around nan khatai :) including mine- my grand mom's version :)
i love these indian cookies....i too made this last week...will post mine soon...urs looks tempting
Hey these look absolutely beautiful. Love the design you have made with the fork. I know what you mean about the shortening texture too - I use it in my favorite gingersnaps recipe, and like you, that is the only thing I use it in, and I hardly make them more than once a year, so why change a good thing.
So little ingredients for such a big taste. TC, thanks for being generous with a second entry :)
It looks delicious. Long ago i've had one
Thank you! Thank you! It is indeed nankatai! In Marathi, that is. We have just about every regional language represented in our family so everyone brings their variation to the table!
This is another lovely version of nankatai! I've exhausted this year's quota of sweets and ghee - I've never used Dalda or shortening.
yup! homemade cookies are the best right?!! your nankatai looks really tasty and soft! I make it at home too, but I stick to butter and loads of almonds:) I love nuts maybe b'coz I'm nuts:D
I don't think I've tasted Nankatai. This looks very good, TC.
Man that's an errand I would have loved too :)
looks yummy yummy
I just love those. Back in India we used to have a lot. hmm thanks for posting such a lovely recipe and helping me to go back to those lovely memories
Looks Good. Seems like its time to back some now :) . thanks for visiting my blog , that lead me to your wonderful blog :), stay tuned...
-Pooja
nankhatai masta jhaliye...mala lahan pani jhup aavdayachi! :) How about sending some over...i am too lazy to make them myself ? ;)
awesome one ...i am late in commenting ...but this is really mouthwatering one ....
Richa: would love to hear about your gnadmother's version.
Remya: Looks forward to your post.
ET: Have you made this yearss quota of gingersnaps :)
Suganya: for you, anything! Even a second entry.
HappyCook, Manisha: Thanks.
Mansi: I'm with you in the nuttiness.
TBC: If you have tasted, you have to. You are sure to like them.
Cynthia: Oh I agree. Being one of the older kids, I kept this errand to myself...didn't delegate.
Sagari, Soumya: Thanks.
Pooja: welcome.
Tee: patta pathav. kharach.
Deepa: Not late at all. The party is always going on :)
Post a Comment